In “Boots Who Ate a Match with the Troll,” an elderly farmer needs his sons to cut timber so he can pay his debts. The two eldest try in turn. Each flees when a troll claims the wood and threatens to kill him. Boots asks for provisions and takes the fresh cheese his mother makes. When the same threat comes, he squeezes the cheese, passing it off as a white stone. The frightened troll bargains for its life by offering its labour. Together they cut a great quantity of timber before evening. [2]
The troll invites Boots home, where they divide the work of preparing porridge. Sent to fetch water, the boy finds two iron pails too heavy to lift. He dismisses them as small basins and proposes carrying back the spring itself. The troll cannot afford to lose its water supply and fetches the water instead. Boots has made his weakness sound like impatience with a task beneath him. The host performs the work while the guest tends the fire. [2]
Over the porridge, Boots proposes an eating match. He secretly hangs his food bag in front of him and spoons more into it than into his mouth. When it fills, he cuts a slit and continues. Eventually the troll can eat no more. Boots advises it to cut an opening in its belly as he apparently has, assuring it that the pain is slight. The troll follows the advice and dies. Boots takes the silver and gold from its hillside home; the money goes towards his father’s debt. The contest’s final trick enriches the family through a killing. [2]
“The Three Billy-Goats Gruff” begins with another claim to territory. Three goats must cross a bridge to reach the hillside grazing. The troll underneath hears each crossing and threatens to eat the traveller. The smallest goat persuades it to wait for his larger companion; the second makes the same argument. By the third crossing the bridge creaks under the biggest goat. He accepts the challenge, drives his horns into the troll’s eyes, crushes its body and throws it into the stream. The goats grow so fat on the hillside that they can scarcely walk home. The appetite that made the troll wait has brought it an opponent it cannot defeat.
The household in Grettir’s Saga has suffered two disappearances before its visitor arrives. In successive winters, a husband and then a servant vanish while the mistress, Steinvor, attends Yule worship. Blood beside the outer door follows the second disappearance. Grettir comes on another Yule eve, calling himself Guest. He carries Steinvor and her daughter together through the flooded, ice-filled river, then returns to wait at the house. His strength unsettles the people he helps: at church, Steinvor says she cannot tell whether a man or a troll carried her across. [3]
Towards midnight a huge troll-wife enters with a trough and a chopper. Grettir rises to meet her. She is stronger, dragging him through the house while their struggle breaks the panelling and tears away the door fittings. Outside, she hauls him towards the river’s deep gorge. At the edge he manages to free his right hand, draw his short sword and cut off her arm. She falls into the water. Exhausted, swollen and bruised, he returns to bed; Steinvor comes home to the wrecked house and learns who her guest really is. [3]
The saga then preserves a competing ending. Grettir says the wounded troll-wife threw herself into the gorge. The people of Bard-dale say daylight caught her during the struggle and that she burst when her arm was cut off: a woman-shaped rock still stands on the cliff. Even within the narrative, survival does not settle the account. The priest also wants visible evidence for Grettir’s belief that the missing men went into the gorge. Their disagreement sends the two back to investigate beneath the waterfall. [3]
The investigation leads Grettir beneath the waterfall into a cave, where a giant attacks him. He cuts through its weapon’s shaft and kills it with his short sword. Seeing bloodied remains in the current, the priest assumes Grettir has died and abandons the rope. Grettir finds the bones of two men, carries them out and climbs unaided. He leaves the bones and a carved account at the church. The priest buries the bones in the churchyard, and the saga says the hauntings cease. The missing men’s story has reached a burial, even while the troll-wife’s fate remains disputed.
Henrik Ibsen’s Peer Gynt makes admission to troll society a disturbing bargain. In Act II, Peer wants the mountain ruler’s daughter and her kingdom. The ruler first demands that he disregard everything beyond the mountains. He then distinguishes the human command to be oneself from the troll command to be sufficient to oneself. Peer accepts, although he barely understands. Marriage and sovereignty make the conditions tolerable to him. [4]
Other concessions follow. Peer drinks what the court serves and allows a tail to be tied onto him. But when the king’s daughters perform, he sees a cow playing a harp and a pig dancing. His blunt description offends the court. The king proposes altering his eyes so that everything ugly will look splendid. Peer asks when his human sight will return. Told that the change is permanent, he refuses. Clothing and a tied-on tail could be removed; a promise could be broken. He will not accept a transformation that leaves no retreat. [4]
The quarrel becomes a trap. The king accuses Peer of desiring his daughter, who declares that she will bear his child. Peer finally admits that he is neither a prince nor rich. Ordered to kill him, the younger trolls pursue him around the hall, blocking each escape. He falls under their attack and calls for his mother. Distant church bells sound; the trolls flee and the palace disappears. Ibsen gives the would-be king a humiliating rescue. He has been willing to adopt the court’s comforts and customs until the bargain threatens his ability to withdraw. [4]
Manuscript checked 2026-10-13. Artistic interpretations © Scott Schubr / Luminary Oddities.